ADVERTISEMENT

Class 3 fact checkers needed

I agree it is an equalizer. But it is also a punishment for winning. Do I believe that privates have an advantage? Yes but not as big as everyong in here makes it out to be. The schools who skirt the rules will either just move to a different school and start all over again or they are to big to get the punishement. Until MSHAA cracks down on them it will continue to happen. But the make private their own class is not really an option either. Can you imagine if we just did away with classes and everyone has to play no matter the schools size in public. The tears would wash this site out but that is what you are wanting to do with privates. What is good for the goose is good for the gander? RIght? If you dont like the rules of the club your school joined tell them leave. People on here think its a government operation. Its not. It is a glorified club which you are free to leave at any time. I wish it was as easy as just seperate privates and public. Personally I am in favor of the championship factor for everyone. I would sure as hell rather win a state championship in a class or two above were you should be.
Separating them is fair and can be done successfully as proven by other states. The champ factor should not apply to publics as they don't have an advantage over other publics. The champ factor can work but not with a 2 class cap and not with 8 points needed to do it. There will be no perfect answer to all as noone can agree but i think most of us agree the current model isnt working.

Class 3 fact checkers needed

no thats an equalizer for the unfair advantage of being able to recruit. I will never understand why privates complain about the field being leveled. most if not all act like they have no advantage or that the publics should just deal with the advantage and say thank you for the opportunity to play lmao
I agree it is an equalizer. But it is also a punishment for winning. Do I believe that privates have an advantage? Yes but not as big as everyong in here makes it out to be. The schools who skirt the rules will either just move to a different school and start all over again or they are to big to get the punishement. Until MSHAA cracks down on them it will continue to happen. But the make private their own class is not really an option either. Can you imagine if we just did away with classes and everyone has to play no matter the schools size in public. The tears would wash this site out but that is what you are wanting to do with privates. What is good for the goose is good for the gander? RIght? If you dont like the rules of the club your school joined tell them leave. People on here think its a government operation. Its not. It is a glorified club which you are free to leave at any time. I wish it was as easy as just seperate privates and public. Personally I am in favor of the championship factor for everyone. I would sure as hell rather win a state championship in a class or two above were you should be.

Travis Hunter number 1 pick?

I've seen a lot about Travis Hunter as being the top pick or at the very least the top prospect. I'm not sure that I understand the thought process behind this. He is undoubtedly a prospect that we haven't seen the likes of for a very long time if ever. However, in the NFL the chances of him playing both ways is basically zero except in special situations I would think. With that being the case, he would have to be either the best DB or the best WR by a lot and he seems to be neither. I can somewhat get on board with him winning the Heisman because he was very good both ways which nobody has done in a very long time. Thoughts?
weakest draft class in memory

Travis Hunter number 1 pick?

I've seen a lot about Travis Hunter as being the top pick or at the very least the top prospect. I'm not sure that I understand the thought process behind this. He is undoubtedly a prospect that we haven't seen the likes of for a very long time if ever. However, in the NFL the chances of him playing both ways is basically zero except in special situations I would think. With that being the case, he would have to be either the best DB or the best WR by a lot and he seems to be neither. I can somewhat get on board with him winning the Heisman because he was very good both ways which nobody has done in a very long time. Thoughts?

Class 3 fact checkers needed

So when a private wins and they get moved up a class or two that is not punishment?
no thats an equalizer for the unfair advantage of being able to recruit. I will never understand why privates complain about the field being leveled. most if not all act like they have no advantage or that the publics should just deal with the advantage and say thank you for the opportunity to play lmao

C5 fact checkers needed

Lincoln College Prep is public (KCPS)
Battle is public. Columbia Independent may be private, so not exactly sure how that works with the co-op.
lincoln is a magnet school which is gray area as shit and im not sure how im going to handle them yet for this scenario.
Battle is public but coop with a private so they go private side.

once again thank you for information

Class 3 fact checkers needed

….so Duchesne has 172 students…. More than half as many as almost all the other schools in class 3???
Record for 2024 was 1-9!!!
Take out their only win against an out of state private academy that had to be MS caliber competition and they averaged one TD a game!!!
Gave up an average of a bunch!!!
And the “success factor” puts them in class 3 !!!

And all “privates” are the same??? Please explain!!!
there are public schools that go undefeated and some that go winless they are the same in that they cannot recruit.
Duchesne was a semi finalist in 22 and district champ in 20 they earned their 3 points. as for win loss this year their failure to recruit doesnt mean we let them out of their champ factor. they are the same as all privates as they can recruit without punishment.

Class 3 fact checkers needed

….so Duchesne has 172 students…. More than half as many as almost all the other schools in class 3???
Record for 2024 was 1-9!!!
Take out their only win against an out of state private academy that had to be MS caliber competition and they averaged one TD a game!!!
Gave up an average of a bunch!!!
And the “success factor” puts them in class 3 !!!

And all “privates” are the same??? Please explain!!!

Surprises of the Season

But,,, Marionville not winning Class 1 was the biggest surprise to me. I wasn't surprised that Adrain won it all. They are in the mix every year.
I feel as if some people were down on Adrian this year. Basically the same Adrian team minus a running back and a few offensive lineman that (had a lead or was trailing by a few points, can’t remember, going into the 4th quarter against Lamar last year )

C5 fact checkers needed

SchoolPrivate/PublicEnrollment
Battle and Columbia independentprivate
1192​
BeltonPublic
1019​
BransonPublic
1075​
CamdentonPublic
973​
Cape CentralPublic
1000​
Capital CityPublic
985​
Cardinal RitterPrivate
339​
CarthagePublic
1227​
Central (springfield)Public
1011​
Central (St Joe)Public
1270​
ChaminadePrivate
816​
EurekaPublic
1209​
FarmingtonPublic
1010​
Fort OsagePublic
1159​
Francis Howell NorthPublic
1262​
Ft Zumwalt northPublic
1155​
Ft Zumwalt WestPublic
1240​
GlendalePublic
1101​
Grain ValleyPublic
1108​
Hazlewood EastPublic
1004​
Helias CatholicPrivate
535​
HillcrestPublic
909​
Jefferson CityPublic
1033​
Ladue Horton WatkinsPublic
1022​
Lafayette WildwoodPublic
1257​
LebanonPublic
1243​
Liberty(wentzville)Public
1234​
Lincoln college prepPublic
910​
MccluerPublic
905​
McCluer NorthPublic
900​
MehlvillePublic
1008​
MICDSPrivate
472​
NeoshoPublic
1182​
North PointPublic
1059​
ParkviewPublic
1037​
Parkway CentralPublic
937​
Parkway SouthPublic
1124​
Parkway WestPublic
1044​
Platte countyPublic
996​
Poplar BluffPublic
1035​
RaytownPublic
977​
RepublicPublic
1109​
Riverview GardensPublic
995​
Rockwood SummitPublic
906​
RollaPublic
1067​
RuskinPublic
977​
Smith CottonPublic
1167​
St Marys South SidePrivate
306​
St.Pius X (kc)Private
326​
TimberlandPublic
1191​
WashingtonPublic
952​
Webb CityPublic
1036​
Webster GrovesPublic
961​
WillardPublic
1045​
William ChrismanPublic
1068​
WinnetonkaPublic
939​
ADVERTISEMENT

Filter

ADVERTISEMENT