MSHSAA might as well wait until all the small schools close

[BoosterBosko]

Here are the numbers of the time frame from when the swimmer was competing against women. There are 10 trans athletes according to the president of the NCAA which is actually less than the 0.002%. Which leave 190k non trans athletes to fill the 99.98. So 1 out of the those 10 trans athletes hit the top echelon of their sport (the swimmer), which is a 10 percent success rate. So non trans athletes would need 19k successful athletes to hit the same success rate. There is not enough championships or top 5 finish spots for them to come close to that top echelon number. Granted this was only for what, one or two years. The fact that it even happened was not on my 21st century bingo card.

Are talking Only D1 NCAA or ALL of NCAA athletes? Because if its ALL NCAA athletes, regardless of division, I'd believe you can hit 19k "successful" non-trans athletes. Think about it. All the different track events. Swimming events. Wrestling. That A LOT of individual athletes reaching peak success. Now do we also include team sports? I BELIEVE in you @HHSX2 !!

 

[HHSX2]

Are talking Only D1 NCAA or ALL of NCAA athletes? Because if its ALL NCAA athletes, regardless of division, I'd believe you can hit 19k "successful" non-trans athletes. Think about it. All the different track events. Swimming events. Wrestling. That A LOT of individual athletes reaching peak success. Now do we also include team sports? I BELIEVE in you @HHSX2 !!

Just D1.

 

[BoosterBosko]

Just D1.

If were just talking D1, I am inclined to agree with you. 19k "successful" NCAA athletes seems far fetched. However, until I see actual proof, I will withhold my likey judgement.

 

[footplayer54]

Here are the numbers of the time frame from when the swimmer was competing against women. There are 10 trans athletes according to the president of the NCAA which is actually less than the 0.002%. Which leave 190k non trans athletes to fill the 99.98. So 1 out of the those 10 trans athletes hit the top echelon of their sport (the swimmer), which is a 10 percent success rate. So non trans athletes would need 19k successful athletes to hit the same success rate. There is not enough championships or top 5 finish spots for them to come close to that top echelon number. Granted this was only for what, one or two years. The fact that it even happened was not on my 21st century bingo card.

This has been the closest to an answer to my question. Thank you