Thought on Missouri postseason, thoughts?

[thesnow.flakegazette]

Hartville basketball coach calls for Missouri playoff changes ahead of No. 1 vs 2 sectional

The No. 1 and 2 teams in the state will play in a Class 2 sectional instead of a state championship. Hartville's coach would like to see a new format.

www.news-leader.com

Came across this on Twitter. Personally I love the idea of reseeding for playoffs and think it should be applied to all sports if applicable.

 

[panther72]

And who do you think is responsible enough to do that? We see what a good job the NCAA does.

 

[thesnow.flakegazette]

And who do you think is responsible enough to do that? We see what a good job the NCAA does.

Who is responsible for seeding districts?

 

[panther72]

The district coaches. They have a seeding meeting.

 

[thesnow.flakegazette]

The district coaches. They have a seeding meeting.

That is my point. Use the same thing for state playoffs. All the playoff teams meet the day after districts are complete and set the bracket. Make the coaches responsible.

Football would be even simpler. Continue the point system through districts.

 

[panther72]

So you want the coaches from 4 corners of the state to meet somewhere and seed teams they have never seen and have no knowledge about?

 

[Veer2Eternity]

That is my point. Use the same thing for state playoffs. All the playoff teams meet the day after districts are complete and set the bracket. Make the coaches responsible.

Football would be even simpler. Continue the point system through districts.

Just use the point system but take out the idiotic Springfield Central angle.

maybe one of our numbers folks could tell us what that'd looked like this year.

 

[thesnow.flakegazette]

So you want the coaches from 4 corners of the state to meet somewhere and seed teams they have never seen and have no knowledge about?

You honestly think all those coaches are unaware and lack all knowledge of the other teams in their class?
You have a better idea or do you just oppose everything?
You seem like one of those “if we can’t help everyone, we will help no one” kinda people.

Mshsaa gets it right as far as determining who the best is. However it doesn’t get it right in rewarding the best teams/individuals. Imagine working your ass off, being one of the top teams in the state and then being in the same district with one of the top teams in the state. If slight tweaks go be made to prevent that, why wouldn’t you? Because it’s not perfect? Nothing will ever be perfect but that doesn’t mean you stop seeking ways to improve.

 

[thesnow.flakegazette]

Just use the point system but take out the idiotic Springfield Central angle.

maybe one of our numbers folks could tell us what that'd looked like this year.

Not sure how to fix that.

 

[panther72]

Basketball Advisory Committee meets at the end of this month. Find the advisory committee member in your area to bring it up at the meeting for a recommendation.

 

[r14veer]

So you want the coaches from 4 corners of the state to meet somewhere and seed teams they have never seen and have no knowledge about?

We do have the technology to not have to be physically together to be able to meet.

 

[thesnow.flakegazette]

Basketball Advisory Committee meets at the end of this month. Find the advisory committee member in your area to bring it up at the meeting for a recommendation.

So as usual you offer nothing.

 

[Veer2Eternity]

Not sure how to fix that.

Don't give play up points. Just use the numbers as is. The SOS stuff works itself out.

 

[Veer2Eternity]

We do have the technology to not have to be physically together to be able to meet.

 

[panther72]

So as usual you offer nothing.

MSHSAA is the only group that can make the change.

 

[Eyezen]

I'm not sure you can objectively seed 16 teams from all over the state, but I think there can be a happy medium and reseed the quarterfinal amongst the 4 sectional teams, who by definition should be more closely aligned and have a higher chance of common opponents etc in which to seed.

Also in my perfect world go back to the neutral sites - but instead of needing 3 sites per quad (2 sectionals and the qtr) make it one site played on Fri and Sat.

 

[MLCcoach]

Hey since it's a basketball proposal we know MSHSAA might actually pay a little more attention to it...

 

[thesnow.flakegazette]

MSHSAA is the only group that can make the change.

What?? I had no clue.

Don't give play up points. Just use the numbers as is. The SOS stuff works itself out.

For some reason I processed as Central playing a weak schedule and seeded higher than better teams. I know it happened a few years ago when they had a winning record

 

[Veer2Eternity]

What?? I had no clue.

For some reason I processed as Central playing a weak schedule and seeded higher than better teams. I know it happened a few years ago when they had a winning record

Right on. that year they lost to 3-8 waynesville in first round of districts.

OOF.

Nobody should get extra credit for playing jabronis.

 

[r14veer]

Right on. that year they lost to 3-8 waynesville in first round of districts.

OOF.

Nobody should get extra credit for playing jabronis.

I wonder if the play-up bonus could be based on opponents' strength as determined by the Supreme Intelligence.

 

[Veer2Eternity]

I wonder if the play-up bonus could be based on opponents' strength as determined by the Supreme Intelligence.

that wouldn't be a play up bonus . That would just be SOS.

 

[thesnow.flakegazette]

I wonder if the play-up bonus could be based on opponents' strength as determined by the Supreme Intelligence.

that wouldn't be a play up bonus . That would just be SOS.

I don't mind the play-up bonus but its value needs to be reduced. I believe it's set a 10 points per class. I say reduce it to 5 and cap it at 10. They also need to increase the value of SOS.

 

[Veer2Eternity]

I don't mind the play-up bonus but its value needs to be reduced. I believe it's set a 10 points per class. I say reduce it to 5 and cap it at 10. They also need to increase the value of SOS.

why should you get play up points for playing bad teams?

Bad is bad regardless of class.