Both are very nice players. “All” has higher end athleticism and in the gym range. “Always” will most likely play D1 after a year at NEO. Hard to say if Carthage or Joplin had the better supporting cast.
Hindsight is 20/20. Carthage was all guards and shooters, which is what All and Always are… so one could say that since there is only 1 basketball to go around, they were better off playing with the athletes at Joplin, the size and athleticism of that supporting cast might have been a better fit, especially if the 6’7 Hafer kid had been healthy last year.
But it would have been fun to see them at Carthage… would have been been 5 guards that could All shoot and attack.