ADVERTISEMENT

Say what u want about the Angels

Duck_walk

Well-Known Member
Oct 17, 2002
23,081
4,231
113
They might do some dumb things but they do try to win.

Kinsler-2b
Trout-CF
Upton-LF
Pujols-1B
Ohtani-DH
Calhoun-RF
Valbuena-3B
Maldonado-C
Simmons-SS
 
Where was this two years ago when they still had a window of opportunity to compete? Better late than never I guess but sheesh you waited until the astros are really good.

Pujols playing 1B with any regularity and hitting fourth would be a disaster.

I suspect am not quite as high on this team as you are. Pitching staff is still really weak. They’ll play some fun games though.
 
Last edited:
They might do some dumb things but they do try to win.

Kinsler-2b
Trout-CF
Upton-LF
Pujols-1B
Ohtani-DH
Calhoun-RF
Valbuena-3B
Maldonado-C
Simmons-SS
When you look at their rotation, how do you think they try to win? And The Mang hitting cleanup and playing 1B...neither of those are proof of trying to win.

They do, however, make some really bad FO decisions. They're not even trying, they've got that mastered.
 
When you look at their rotation, how do you think they try to win? And The Mang hitting cleanup and playing 1B...neither of those are proof of trying to win.

They do, however, make some really bad FO decisions. They're not even trying, they've got that mastered.

Come on. I know you and 21 like to play tough guy here. They have added Kinsler, Upton and Ohtani. Stop it. They arent finished yet.
 
Come on. I know you and 21 like to play tough guy here. They have added Kinsler, Upton and Ohtani. Stop it. They arent finished yet.
You do realize Kinsler is 36 and is probably in the middle of a big decline, right? We'll see, but they've got to pitch. I'd much rather have the Birds active and 40 man rosters.
 
You do realize Kinsler is 36 and is probably in the middle of a big decline, right? We'll see, but they've got to pitch. I'd much rather have the Birds active and 40 man rosters.
Certainly our 40 man. Probably our 25 man once we're done making moves, especially if Ohtani isn't 200 innings of Carlos Martinez level pitching or better.

Angels really had to go for it now (although now was really 2016, not 2018)
 
Come on. I know you and 21 like to play tough guy here. They have added Kinsler, Upton and Ohtani. Stop it. They arent finished yet.
I believe the Birds have finished with a better record every year since Albert signed with them.
 
I believe the Birds have finished with a better record every year since Albert signed with them.
Quite believable, they are a terribly run team from the owner down. The poster child for signing old players to ridiculous deals.

This team gave nearly half a billion to Pujols, Josh Hamilton, and CJ Wilson over 2 consecutive offseasons. Amazing stuff.
 
I believe the Birds have finished with a better record every year since Albert signed with them.

I know this. Im just talking about this off season. They are going for it in 2018. I didnt mean anything else. And I wasnt comparing them to STL. I simply noted they have made 3 major pick ups. If I was an Angels fan, I would be appreciative. Kinsler is still a pro's pro. He is the kind of vet the birds used to pick up to put them in the hunt to beat the pond scum Mets.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vbsideout
I know this. Im just talking about this off season. They are going for it in 2018. I didnt mean anything else. And I wasnt comparing them to STL. I simply noted they have made 3 major pick ups. If I was an Angels fan, I would be appreciative. Kinsler is still a pro's pro. He is the kind of vet the birds used to pick up to put them in the hunt to beat the pond scum Mets.
Kinsler isn't major. He's barely minor anymore. The other two are quality players. I know this, I'm glad I'm not an Angels fan.
 

Come on. Admit it. You didnt realize he had 6+ war in 2015 and 2016. He was banged up in 2017 and didnt perform to his level--(still had a 2+) but is healthy again. I hope you arent dissing WAR. Its ok to admit you didnt know bro. How many of your beloved redbirds have ever had a 6+??? Come on bro.
 
Come on. Admit it. You didnt realize he had 6+ war in 2015 and 2016. He was banged up in 2017 and didnt perform to his level--(still had a 2+) but is healthy again. I hope you arent dissing WAR. Its ok to admit you didnt know bro. How many of your beloved redbirds have ever had a 6+??? Come on bro.
I did. And I also realize he's 36 and very likely to have a huge decline. If the Birds had signed him I would've reacted about the same way I did to the Fowler signing. Great, the Angels are going for it. And they're still going to suck. Ian Kinsler isn't going to change that.
 
I did. And I also realize he's 36 and very likely to have a huge decline. If the Birds had signed him I would've reacted about the same way I did to the Fowler signing. Great, the Angels are going for it. And they're still going to suck. Ian Kinsler isn't going to change that.

Ok.

I just wish the birds would go ahead and make the next big deal. Handling this anxiety is not my forte.
 
Come on. Admit it. You didnt realize he had 6+ war in 2015 and 2016. He was banged up in 2017 and didnt perform to his level--(still had a 2+) but is healthy again. I hope you arent dissing WAR. Its ok to admit you didnt know bro. How many of your beloved redbirds have ever had a 6+??? Come on bro.
This would be a lot more meaningful if he weren't over 35 years old.
 
I did. And I also realize he's 36 and very likely to have a huge decline. If the Birds had signed him I would've reacted about the same way I did to the Fowler signing. Great, the Angels are going for it. And they're still going to suck. Ian Kinsler isn't going to change that.
He's replacing a spot where the angels were absolutely dreadful last year, so there is real value in him being a ~2-3 win player. He's not a stud anymore, but league average performance at 2B is still a good upgrade for the Angels.
 
A closer + one more position player would go a long way, don't you think?
I agree Neut, but my thoughts are they will go get A. Reed or some cheaper type RP and go closer by committee and be done. Hope I'm wrong but once they got Ozuna they probably patted themselves on the back and headed back to St. Louis for the ground breaking ceremony for ballpark village. Hope I'm wrong, but I just don't see them giving up their young guns for Colome, but that would be the trade I hope they make.
 
He's replacing a spot where the angels were absolutely dreadful last year, so there is real value in him being a ~2-3 win player. He's not a stud anymore, but league average performance at 2B is still a good upgrade for the Angels.
I was willing to put money on them going after Castro. Young enough, cheap enough, high contact guy to mix in with their power bats

Did not see Kinsler being a fit
 
I agree Neut, but my thoughts are they will go get A. Reed or some cheaper type RP and go closer by committee and be done. Hope I'm wrong but once they got Ozuna they probably patted themselves on the back and headed back to St. Louis for the ground breaking ceremony for ballpark village. Hope I'm wrong, but I just don't see them giving up their young guns for Colome, but that would be the trade I hope they make.
I haven't seen anything about the Cards looking hard at Reed. Not that they couldn't be. But the chatter seems more focused on Davis.
 
I was willing to put money on them going after Castro. Young enough, cheap enough, high contact guy to mix in with their power bats

Did not see Kinsler being a fit
Simmons/Kinsler is a heck of a defensive combo for a team whose rotation doesn't exactly lead the world in Ks
 
  • Like
Reactions: Duck_walk
Simmons/Kinsler is a heck of a defensive combo for a team whose rotation doesn't exactly lead the world in Ks
Also true, but Castro at 2nd isn't as bad as the metrics/stats play out

And let's be honest, with their pitching.....They are just trying to out hit everyone now. Pitching and defense are just bonus points
 
Also true, but Castro at 2nd isn't as bad as the metrics/stats play out

And let's be honest, with their pitching.....They are just trying to out hit everyone now. Pitching and defense are just bonus points
Eh, they are going to be a really good defensive team when Pujols isn't on the field. Trout is a fine CF. Their catcher is good. Simmons is divine. They gotta be top 5 in the league at D unless their corner players are millstones
 
Eh, they are going to be a really good defensive team when Pujols isn't on the field. Trout and Upton are fine. Their catcher is good. Simmons is divine.
I could watch Simmons, Russell and Lindor all day long and never get bored
 
I'm sorry, I believe you misspelled Diaz, DeJong, and Peralta.
ywpPHgu.gif
 
I could watch Simmons, Russell and Lindor all day long and never get bored
Can we throw in Baez for theatrical performances too? I know he might struggle with the routine sometimes, but holy heck that is one athletic dude.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT