How are all the "Transfers" to Trinity not raising seriouse red flags with MSHSAA??

[wcfanfourever]

we had a kicker transfer from Webb to Nevada a few years ago that had to set out a year.

This is classic example of why private schools need to be in their own classification

 

[bhunt95]

unless the school person transfers from checks the box that says they believe person transfering for Athletic reasons they dont have to sit out.

 

[wcfanfourever]

Yea I know the rule. Smells like a week old carp

 

[Bleeding Red and Black]

Why in the world would a kicker who was transferring FROM Webb to Nevada mark that box anyways. That's just stupid. I mean had he been transferring to Webb I could see.

 

[Anders4]

Get over the private/public chit. Life is not fair. 4 classifications have 0 private schools in the state championship.

Webb didn't care when they played Helias and MICDS. Nobody that plays or coaches cares. Everybody has to find something to complain about these days.

Webb didn't make it, life will move on.

 

[Kzar]

Just stomp them and the point is moot. I had more respect in Lamar and their fans than to see the public v private crap get started.

 

[96 PowerCat]

Just stomp them and the point is moot. I had more respect in Lamar and their fans than to see the public v private crap get started.

Lamar fans didn't start this thread.

 

[anon_utvqikut1knht]

Didn't seem to deter Penney last Saturday................

 

[sbdude]

we had a kicker transfer from Webb to Nevada a few years ago that had to set out a year.

This is classic example of why private schools need to be in their own classification

That kicker had to sit out because of Webb's AD or administration. If Webb hadn't checked the box, he would have been eligible immediately, just like stated in another post.

 

[Rufus R. Jones]

Didn't seem to deter Penney last Saturday................

Heard some old dude after the game in Lawson Saturday whining and bitching about private schools, too. Just too easy to throw out there when your best wasn't good enough. Came off as being pretty pathetic.

 

[touchdownsilly]

Yeah I hear yeah I love it when I see old people upset and can call them pathetic. Did you even know who the man was, he could have been a veteran, a war hero, a doctor who saved lives, etc. Pathetic is getting on message boards to make your self feel better and make fun of other people. I personally think it is hilarious that private schools recruit and MSHSAA does nothing about it. It will make us working class people stronger in the end and fight for everything we get.

 

[wcfanfourever]

Yeah I hear yeah I love it when I see old people upset and can call them pathetic. Did you even know who the man was, he could have been a veteran, a war hero, a doctor who saved lives, etc. Pathetic is getting on message boards to make your self feel better and make fun of other people. I personally think it is hilarious that private schools recruit and MSHSAA does nothing about it. It will make us working class people stronger in the end and fight for everything we get.

It's not about who can beat who, I think Lamar wins by 21. It's about what's right and what's wrong

 

[Mike*Honcho]

... whining and bitching about private schools. Came off as being pretty pathetic.

What is pathetic is taking wins and a trophy when you don't play by the same rules as everyone else. Some might even call that cheating (and yes, creating rules that favor one group over another is cheating, even if it is written into the rules).

One group (publics) is only allowed to use players that live within their district/school boundaries. The other can take players from anywhere, even other states. It is pathetic that this is allowed. Just another rigged system that favors those in power.

 

[hangmanbobbyjaggers]

Didn't seem to deter Penney last Saturday................

If it had, many would say that Valle recruited too many kids. Even was stated they must not have recruited well enough this year! I coach, I do not care about the recruitment. I do care that the kids recruited DO NOT PAY TUITION! That is the part that should not happen! PERIOD.... Your choice to attend, but kids should pay their way for that private education, not donors and fund raising events.

 

[cr7707]

How is kearney's transfer QB not raising serious red flags with the MSHSAA?

 

[MIZSEC21]

How is kearney's transfer QB not raising serious red flags with the MSHSAA?

Did his family move within the district? If they did, nothing to see here

 

[Rufus R. Jones]

Yeah I hear yeah I love it when I see old people upset and can call them pathetic. Did you even know who the man was, he could have been a veteran, a war hero, a doctor who saved lives, etc. Pathetic is getting on message boards to make your self feel better and make fun of other people. I personally think it is hilarious that private schools recruit and MSHSAA does nothing about it. It will make us working class people stronger in the end and fight for everything we get.

Yeah, pretty sure he was all of those things, along with being a whiny, pathetic excuse-maker.

 

[ILHSFB]

That kicker had to sit out because of Webb's AD or administration. If Webb hadn't checked the box, he would have been eligible immediately, just like stated in another post.

You are misinformed dude, and you are clueless in this situation!

 

[TinHornMan]

You are misinformed dude, and you are clueless in this situation!

Go on.....

 

[Flint222]

Stamp it.

 

[TheDaddy]

Kearney QB his family moved before the end of the 2016 school year student finished out his year with Excelsior Springs. If there were flags Excelsior Springs raised them.

 

[wcfanfourever]

Kearney QB his family moved before the end of the 2016 school year student finished out his year with Excelsior Springs. If there were flags Excelsior Springs raised them.

If he didn't move at the same time as his family he isn't eligible. Rule seems pretty clear cut

 

[l_Pete_l]

Pointing out an area where the rules might have been violated or needs to be changed is hardly crying. To gain an unfair advantage isn't right whether it's a biased ref or a violation of a rule. Separating public and private isn't the answer imo and in the opinion of people who have to deal with the separation. There would be no governing of the private schools then and they would recruit kids from all around. With that said there need to be supervision of kids transferring that extends beyond a sister private school reporting it. As with our society, when new violations are found there needs to be a review of the rules. Trinity has more than pushed the boundaries of the rules and anyone who thinks mentioning it is crying I want to ref your next sporting event and see if you dislike the unfair advantage I would biasedly create.

 

[bhunt95]

Think it depends on what happens today. If Lamar wins nobody will care. But if Lamar loses going be alot of complaing about private school recruiting.