ADVERTISEMENT

NFL 100 All time QB

kaching

kaching

Well-Known Member
Feb 27, 2002
2,805
829
113
Brady and Montana have already been named to the list so there are only 8 spots left for the following : manning, young, Unitas, brees, Bradshaw, Baugh, Aikman, Elway, Favre, Fouts, Layne, Graham, Starr, Rodgers, tarkenton, Marino, Van Brocklin, Staubach, Namath

Tough to pick just eight more - realizing the other lists have included quite a few old timers, I’m guessing Unitas, Baugh, Van Brocklin, Marino, Manning, Favre, Elway, rodgers...
 
Last edited:
My top 10 prediction:

1. Joe Montana
2. Tom Brady
3. PeytonManning
4. Johnny Unitas
5. Otto Graham
6. Sammy Baugh
7. Dan Marino
8. John Elway
9. Roger Staubach
10. Terry Bradshaw

Brees will be added at a later date. Possibly Rodgers. Favre?


My personal top 10 favorites.

1. Unitas
2. P Manning
3. Fouts
4. J Kelly
5. Bradshaw
6. Kurt Warner
7. Brees
8. Elway
9. Bert Jones
10. Jim Hart
 
Duck_walk said:
My top 10 prediction:

1. Joe Montana
2. Tom Brady
3. PeytonManning
4. Johnny Unitas
5. Otto Graham
6. Sammy Baugh
7. Dan Marino
8. John Elway
9. Roger Staubach
10. Terry Bradshaw

Brees will be added at a later date. Possibly Rodgers Favre? Mahomes...


My personal top 10 favorites.

1. Unitas
2. P Manning
3. Fouts
4. J Kelly
5. Bradshaw
6. Kurt Warner
7. Brees
8. Elway
9. Bert Jones
10. Jim Hart
Click to expand...
Fixt...
 
1. Tom Brady
74,350 passing yards (2nd all-time)
539 passing touchdowns (2nd all time)
97.0 passer rating (5th all time)
63.9 completion % (16th all time)

2. Joe Montana
40,551 passing yards (20th All-time)
273 passing touchdowns (17th all time)
92.3 passer rating (15th all time)
63.2 completion % (19th all time)

3. Peyton Manning
71,940 passing yards (3rd All Time)
539 passing touchdowns (3rd all time)
96.5 passer rating (8th all time)
65.3 completion % (7th all time)

4. Johnny Unitas
40,239 passing yards (21st all time)
290 passing touchdowns (15th all time)
78.2 passer rating (89th all time)
54.6 completion % (136 all time)

5. Drew Brees
77,163 passing yards (1st All-Time)
544 passing touchdowns (1st All time)
98.3 passer rating (3rd all time)
67.7 completion % (1st all time)

6. Sonny Jurgenson
32,224 passing yards (42 all time)
255 passing touchdowns (20th all time)
82.6 passer rating (52nd all time)
57.1 completion % (92nd all time)

7. Otto Graham
23,584 passing yards (87th all time)
174 passing touchdowns (63rd all time)
86.6 passer rating (32nd all time)
55.8 completion % (119th all time)

8. Brett Favre
71,838 passing yards (4th all time)
508 passing touchdowns (4th all time)
86.0 (35th all time)
62.0 completion % (30th all time)

9. Sammy Baugh
21,866 passing yards (98th all time)
187 passing touchdowns (55th all time)
72.2 passer rating (141st all time)
56.5 completion % (105th all time)

10. Warren Moon
49325 passing yards NFL (11th all time)
*70,355 total passing yards (NFL,CFL,USFL)
291 passing touchdowns (14th all time)
*435 total passing touchdowns
80.9 passer rating (68th all time)
58.4 completion % (74th all time)

Honorable mention:

John Elway
Dan Marino
Jim Kelly
Fran Tarkenton
Roger Staubach
Terry Bradshaw
Kurt Warner
Dan Fouts
Aaron Rodgers
 
Veerman_12 said:
1. Tom Brady
74,350 passing yards (2nd all-time)
539 passing touchdowns (2nd all time)
97.0 passer rating (5th all time)
63.9 completion % (16th all time)

2. Joe Montana
40,551 passing yards (20th All-time)
273 passing touchdowns (17th all time)
92.3 passer rating (15th all time)
63.2 completion % (19th all time)

3. Peyton Manning
71,940 passing yards (3rd All Time)
539 passing touchdowns (3rd all time)
96.5 passer rating (8th all time)
65.3 completion % (7th all time)

4. Johnny Unitas
40,239 passing yards (21st all time)
290 passing touchdowns (15th all time)
78.2 passer rating (89th all time)
54.6 completion % (136 all time)

5. Drew Brees
77,163 passing yards (1st All-Time)
544 passing touchdowns (1st All time)
98.3 passer rating (3rd all time)
67.7 completion % (1st all time)

6. Sonny Jurgenson
32,224 passing yards (42 all time)
255 passing touchdowns (20th all time)
82.6 passer rating (52nd all time)
57.1 completion % (92nd all time)

7. Otto Graham
23,584 passing yards (87th all time)
174 passing touchdowns (63rd all time)
86.6 passer rating (32nd all time)
55.8 completion % (119th all time)

8. Brett Favre
71,838 passing yards (4th all time)
508 passing touchdowns (4th all time)
86.0 (35th all time)
62.0 completion % (30th all time)

9. Sammy Baugh
21,866 passing yards (98th all time)
187 passing touchdowns (55th all time)
72.2 passer rating (141st all time)
56.5 completion % (105th all time)

10. Warren Moon
49325 passing yards NFL (11th all time)
*70,355 total passing yards (NFL,CFL,USFL)
291 passing touchdowns (14th all time)
*435 total passing touchdowns
80.9 passer rating (68th all time)
58.4 completion % (74th all time)

Honorable mention:

John Elway
Dan Marino
Jim Kelly
Fran Tarkenton
Roger Staubach
Terry Bradshaw
Kurt Warner
Dan Fouts
Aaron Rodgers Patrick Mahomes
Click to expand...
Fixt again...
 
Hard to compare different eras. Johnny U called all his plays, rules were so different, fewer games per yr. Hard to compare with recent pass happy league. Today's qbs would be hard pressed to play past 35 yoa if they took the hits they did up thru the late 80's to early 90's. Pass rushers would have eaten up many of today's QBs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MoSooner69 and I2R I
stocktiger82 said:
Hard to compare different eras. Johnny U called all his plays, rules were so different, fewer games per yr. Hard to compare with recent pass happy league. Today's qbs would be hard pressed to play past 35 yoa if they took the hits they did up thru the late 80's to early 90's. Pass rushers would have eaten up many of today's QBs.
Click to expand...

comparing passing stats from the 60s-70s with today is really just silly and shows a lack of historical knowledge.
 
  • Like
Reactions: I2R I
Veerman_12 said:
1. Tom Brady
74,350 passing yards (2nd all-time)
539 passing touchdowns (2nd all time)
97.0 passer rating (5th all time)
63.9 completion % (16th all time)

2. Joe Montana
40,551 passing yards (20th All-time)
273 passing touchdowns (17th all time)
92.3 passer rating (15th all time)
63.2 completion % (19th all time)

3. Peyton Manning
71,940 passing yards (3rd All Time)
539 passing touchdowns (3rd all time)
96.5 passer rating (8th all time)
65.3 completion % (7th all time)

4. Johnny Unitas
40,239 passing yards (21st all time)
290 passing touchdowns (15th all time)
78.2 passer rating (89th all time)
54.6 completion % (136 all time)

5. Drew Brees
77,163 passing yards (1st All-Time)
544 passing touchdowns (1st All time)
98.3 passer rating (3rd all time)
67.7 completion % (1st all time)

6. Sonny Jurgenson
32,224 passing yards (42 all time)
255 passing touchdowns (20th all time)
82.6 passer rating (52nd all time)
57.1 completion % (92nd all time)

7. Otto Graham
23,584 passing yards (87th all time)
174 passing touchdowns (63rd all time)
86.6 passer rating (32nd all time)
55.8 completion % (119th all time)

8. Brett Favre
71,838 passing yards (4th all time)
508 passing touchdowns (4th all time)
86.0 (35th all time)
62.0 completion % (30th all time)

9. Sammy Baugh
21,866 passing yards (98th all time)
187 passing touchdowns (55th all time)
72.2 passer rating (141st all time)
56.5 completion % (105th all time)

10. Warren Moon
49325 passing yards NFL (11th all time)
*70,355 total passing yards (NFL,CFL,USFL)
291 passing touchdowns (14th all time)
*435 total passing touchdowns
80.9 passer rating (68th all time)
58.4 completion % (74th all time)

Honorable mention:

John Elway
Dan Marino
Jim Kelly
Fran Tarkenton
Roger Staubach
Terry Bradshaw
Kurt Warner
Dan Fouts
Aaron Rodgers
Click to expand...

Silly little man. Comparing stats from different eras like its baseball. Cute. Look up all the rule changes that have occurred over the years about downfield pass interference and holding. THe stats are meaningless. We won't even go into the rules that protect the QB. Let's just say, Brady would not have played past 36 years old, if he played in the 70s and 80s, because people like Lawrence Taylor would have been purposely taking his ass out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MoSooner69
Here is a little lesson on how football used to be played when they still actually had bounties on players --especially quarterbacks.

 
HOly cow, Brady only made it #5 on two of the SB passer rating and completion % lists for career or game? Imagine that? Hmmm?

Super Bowl Game Passer Rating

Game Passer Rating
1. Phil Simms • NYG · XXI 150.9
2. Joe Montana • SFO · XXIV 147.6
3. Jim Plunkett • OAK · XV 145
4. Matt Ryan • ATL · LI 144.1
5. Troy Aikman • DAL · XXVII 140.7
6. Steve Young • SFO · XXIX 134.8
7. Doug Williams • WAS · XXII 127.9
8. Joe Montana • SFO · XIX 127.2
9. Joe Flacco • BAL · XLVII 124.2
10. Russell Wilson • SEA · XLVIII 123.1

Super Bowl Career Passer Rating

Career Passer Rating
1. Joe Montana • 4G 127.8
2. Jim Plunkett • 2G 122.8
3. Russell Wilson • 2G 117.4
4. Terry Bradshaw • 4G 112.8
5. Troy Aikman • 3G 111.9
6. Nick Foles • 1G 106.1
7. Bart Starr • 2G 106
8. Brett Favre • 2G 97.6
9. Kurt Warner • 3G 96.7
10. Eli Manning • 2G 96.2

Super Bowl Game COmpletion %

Game Pass Completion %
1. Phil Simms • NYG · XXI 88
2. Drew Brees • NOR · XLIV 82.1
3. Joe Montana • SFO · XXIV 75.9
4. Eli Manning • NYG · XLVI 75
5. Tom Brady • NWE · XLIX 74
6. Matt Ryan • ATL · LI 73.9
7. Ken Anderson • CIN · XVI 73.5
8. Troy Aikman • DAL · XXVII 73.3
9. Kurt Warner • ARI · XLIII 72.1
10. Russell Wilson • SEA · XLVIII 72

Career Passer % Rating Super Bowl


1. Troy Aikman • 3G 70
2. Joe Montana • 4G 68
3. Peyton Manning • 4G 66.5
4. Eli Manning • 2G 66.2
5. Tom Brady • 9G 65.3
6. Russell Wilson • 2G 65.2
7. Nick Foles • 1G 65.1
8. Len Dawson • 2G 63.6
9. Bob Griese • 3G 63.4
10. Jim Plunkett • 2G 63
 
Last edited:
JNreturns said:
Silly little man. Comparing stats from different eras like its baseball. Cute. Look up all the rule changes that have occurred over the years about downfield pass interference and holding. THe stats are meaningless. We won't even go into the rules that protect the QB. Let's just say, Brady would not have played past 36 years old, if he played in the 70s and 80s, because people like Lawrence Taylor would have been purposely taking his ass out.
Click to expand...

Dear lord, you and Duck are just excited to criticize and complain...worse than women. That wasn't a stat comparison, it was just showing where they stood all time and providing statistics.

If I was basing that top 10 (my top 10) on stats without taking eras, rule changes, and longevity into account, I wouldn't have had Sammy Baugh, Sonny Jurgenson, or Otto Graham on my list at all.

Do you want to discuss who's on my list or get into a nonsensical debate about stats? Who on that list do you disagree with and why?

1. Tom Brady

2. Joe Montana

3. Peyton Manning

4. Johnny Unitas

5. Drew Brees

6. Sonny Jurgenson

7. Otto Graham

8. Brett Favre

9. Sammy Baugh

10. Warren Moon

There, no stats, what do you disagree with?
 
Last edited:
Favre in Bradshaw out. Otherwise I nailed it.

Brady, Favre, Montana, Manning, Unitas, Graham, Baugh, Staubach, Elway, Marino
 
Last edited:
Bart Starr will probably be a top 10 QB. Arguably the best QB of the 1960s, on the best team of the 1960s. While he may not have eye-popping stats, he was a 5-time NFL champion, including the first 2 Super Bowls.
 
justaconcernedcitizen said:
Bart Starr will probably be a top 10 QB. Arguably the best QB of the 1960s, on the best team of the 1960s. While he may not have eye-popping stats, he was a 5-time NFL champion, including the first 2 Super Bowls.
Click to expand...

They already released the list. He wasnt on it.
 
kaching said:
Brady and Montana have already been named to the list so there are only 8 spots left for the following : manning, young, Unitas, brees, Bradshaw, Baugh, Aikman, Elway, Favre, Fouts, Layne, Graham, Starr, Rodgers, tarkenton, Marino, Van Brocklin, Staubach, Namath

Tough to pick just eight more - realizing the other lists have included quite a few old timers, I’m guessing Unitas, Baugh, Van Brocklin, Marino, Manning, Favre, Elway, rodgers...
Click to expand...

Miss it by two . Graham for Van Brocklin, Staubach for Rodgers...
 
Underated Tarkenton from 61-78. 6-0 190. After he retired, it took over 20 years for anybody to better his career passing yard totals.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT
Top Bottom
Back