1999-00
- Bears lost a bad road game to UMKC in December - William Fontleroy was injured and didn't play, which led to the loss in my opinion. The NCAA didn't take the injury into account when debating the Bears as an at-large team (more on that later).
- MSU lost to SMU in the finals of their on-campus tourney in early December, which would've been their best non-conf. victory.
- As usual with Alford & Hinson, they lost a couple of times late to cost them a chance at a MVC regular season title
Due to those three issues, they missed out on an at-large bid with an RIP of 36, if I recall correctly. Ironically, the Bears defeated SMU in a first round NIT home game, I wish they would've won the regular season game three months before. Ole Miss blasted them in a NIT second round game. They really missed Danny Moore as an inside guy.
2000-05
The Bears had several 17-11 like teams, borderline NIT candidates. This is when Hinson should've been let-go, in my opinion.
2005-06
MSU had an RPI of 21, but was left out of the NCAA Tournament field.
Working against them...
- The MVC got four teams that season - There's ZERO chance the NCAA was going to put five MVC teams in the tourney
- The Bears had zero quality non-conf. wins
- The Bears lost their first (a quarterfinal) MVC tourney game to Northern Iowa
- Bradley was included in the NCAA field (and made a run to the Sweet 16), because the NCAA took into account the injury of Patrick O'Bryant for much of the season, which they didn't do for the Bears in '99-'00.
- MSU did make a run to the NIT quarters, but were outmatched by Louisville.
2006-07
The Bears pulled off their best ever regular season Div. I win in program history by defeating #7 Wisconsin in a November tourney, BUT they were manhandled in a home, bracket-buster contest against (I think) Davidson and lost an ESPN2 home conference game against SIU, also playing rather poorly.
So, the very very good non-conf. win was wasted by a lackluster February. The NCAA left the Bears out of the field with an RPI of about 34.
This was also the season where the Bears beat Evansville by 50, then lost to them by 7 a week later. Nothing sums up the Hinson era better than that one.
2010-11
The Bears and Cuonzo Martin won the programs only regular season MVC title, BUT they didn't have a single quality non-conf. win and their RPI wasn't all that great, so they became the first regular season MVC champ left out of the NCAA field since the late/mid-80's.