ADVERTISEMENT

How much does SIZE matter?

JNreturns

Well-Known Member
Aug 1, 2016
4,700
1,860
113
Kansas City, MO
Okay, I'm not talking about to your girlfriends or wives opinion...I'm talking about making it to the state championship game. If you break down each classification into four quartiles by size (25% each), how does it look? Well, here are the last 10 years worth of results. Each classification has 20 schools that represented (2 in each state championship game, from 2008 to 2017.)

Class 6
12/20 Top Quartile in size

5/20 Second quartile.
So that leaves only 3 teams out of 20 that have been in the bottom 50% in size that have made the final. Francis-Howell, Columbia Rockbridge, and Kirkwood.
In Class 6, size appears to matter a great deal.

Class 5
Has the lowest size differential from top to bottom in all the classes. Still 12/20 are from the top 2 quartiles. Seven teams made it from the 4th quartile. Certainly, size doesn't matter as much when you have a lower size differential.

Class 4
12/20 from the top quartile
(Webb and Kearney). There are five teams from the 3rd quartile...but they are private schools..Helias and MICDS. Harrisonville is the only 3rd quartile public school. No 4th quartile teams have been to the finals the past ten years. Looks like size, or recruiting capability, matter considerably. Doesn't help that outside of Class 1, the largest size differential of any class.

Class 3

Completely bucks the trend. Only 5/20 from the top 50%. Maryville, a bottom quartile team, has four appearances in the final. Burroughs, as a 3rd quartile team, has five appearances in the final. Size doesn't seem to matter much in Class 3.

Class 2
Back to size mattering.. 14/20 from the top 2 quartiles.
Only Lawson and Trinity Catholic from the 3rd quartile.


Maryville is pound for pound, the best performer based on size.
 
Last edited:
Okay, I'm not talking about to your girlfriends or wives...I'm talking about making it to the state championship game. If you break down each classification into four quartiles by size (25% each), how does it look? Well, here are the last 10 years worth of results. Each classification has 20 schools that represented (2 in each state championship game, from 2008 to 2017.)

Class 6
12/20 Top Quartile in size

5/20 Second quartile.
So that leaves only 3 teams out of 20 that have been in the bottom 50% in size that have made the final. Francis-Howell, Columbia Rockbridge, and Kirkwood.
In Class 6, size appears to matter a great deal.

Class 5
Has the lowest size differential from top to bottom in all the classes. Still 12/20 are from the top 2 quartiles. Seven teams made it from the 4th quartile. Certainly, size doesn't matter as much when you have a lower size differential.

Class 4
12/20 from the top quartile
(Webb and Kearney). There are five teams from the 3rd quartile...but they are private schools..Helias and MICDS. Harrisonville is the only 3rd quartile public school. No 4th quartile teams have been to the finals the past ten years. Looks like size, or recruiting capability, matter considerably.

Class 3

Completely bucks the trend. Only 5/20 from the top 50%. Maryville, a bottom quartile team, has four appearances in the final. Burroughs, as a 3rd quartile team, has five appearances in the final. Size doesn't seem to matter much in Class 3.

Class 2
Back to size mattering.. 14/20 from the top 2 quartiles.
Only Lawson and Trinity Catholic from the 3rd quartile.


Maryville is pound for pound, the best performer based on size.
About the 5th time you have brought up this topic.
trOyEUO.gif
 
  • Like
Reactions: BoosterBosko
The data I have to work with on school enrollment gets crazy below Class 2. Class 1 has by far the biggest disparity in school enrollments. And there is a random element to it with schools varying drastically from year to year in enrollment--going from 8-man to 11-man.
 
Okay, I'm not talking about to your girlfriends or wives opinion...I'm talking about making it to the state championship game. If you break down each classification into four quartiles by size (25% each), how does it look? Well, here are the last 10 years worth of results. Each classification has 20 schools that represented (2 in each state championship game, from 2008 to 2017.)

Class 6
12/20 Top Quartile in size

5/20 Second quartile.
So that leaves only 3 teams out of 20 that have been in the bottom 50% in size that have made the final. Francis-Howell, Columbia Rockbridge, and Kirkwood.
In Class 6, size appears to matter a great deal.

Class 5
Has the lowest size differential from top to bottom in all the classes. Still 12/20 are from the top 2 quartiles. Seven teams made it from the 4th quartile. Certainly, size doesn't matter as much when you have a lower size differential.

Class 4
12/20 from the top quartile
(Webb and Kearney). There are five teams from the 3rd quartile...but they are private schools..Helias and MICDS. Harrisonville is the only 3rd quartile public school. No 4th quartile teams have been to the finals the past ten years. Looks like size, or recruiting capability, matter considerably. Doesn't help that outside of Class 1, the largest size differential of any class.

Class 3

Completely bucks the trend. Only 5/20 from the top 50%. Maryville, a bottom quartile team, has four appearances in the final. Burroughs, as a 3rd quartile team, has five appearances in the final. Size doesn't seem to matter much in Class 3.

Class 2
Back to size mattering.. 14/20 from the top 2 quartiles.
Only Lawson and Trinity Catholic from the 3rd quartile.


Maryville is pound for pound, the best performer based on size.

giphy.gif
 
Okay, I'm not talking about to your girlfriends or wives opinion...I'm talking about making it to the state championship game. If you break down each classification into four quartiles by size (25% each), how does it look? Well, here are the last 10 years worth of results. Each classification has 20 schools that represented (2 in each state championship game, from 2008 to 2017.)

Class 6
12/20 Top Quartile in size

5/20 Second quartile.
So that leaves only 3 teams out of 20 that have been in the bottom 50% in size that have made the final. Francis-Howell, Columbia Rockbridge, and Kirkwood.
In Class 6, size appears to matter a great deal.

Class 5
Has the lowest size differential from top to bottom in all the classes. Still 12/20 are from the top 2 quartiles. Seven teams made it from the 4th quartile. Certainly, size doesn't matter as much when you have a lower size differential.

Class 4
12/20 from the top quartile
(Webb and Kearney). There are five teams from the 3rd quartile...but they are private schools..Helias and MICDS. Harrisonville is the only 3rd quartile public school. No 4th quartile teams have been to the finals the past ten years. Looks like size, or recruiting capability, matter considerably. Doesn't help that outside of Class 1, the largest size differential of any class.

Class 3

Completely bucks the trend. Only 5/20 from the top 50%. Maryville, a bottom quartile team, has four appearances in the final. Burroughs, as a 3rd quartile team, has five appearances in the final. Size doesn't seem to matter much in Class 3.

Class 2
Back to size mattering.. 14/20 from the top 2 quartiles.
Only Lawson and Trinity Catholic from the 3rd quartile.


Maryville is pound for pound, the best performer based on size.


Colquitt is the 25th largest school in Georgia, and should have won three of the last four state championships! Course, having the greatest head coach on the planet don't hurt!
 
Colquitt is the 25th largest school in Georgia, and should have won three of the last four state championships! Course, having the greatest head coach on the planet don't hurt!
Should have won 3 of the last 4 State championships? How many did they win? If it wasn't all 4, it's unreasonable to call him the greatest coach in Georgia, much less the planet.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT